The sales and marketing SLA that ends the 'leads are rubbish' argument

The Sales Architect title card reading: The sales and marketing SLA that ends the 'leads are rubbish' argument

A sales and marketing SLA (service level agreement) is a one-page document that swaps the ‘leads are rubbish’ argument for commitments on both sides. Marketing commits to a lead definition and a monthly volume. Sales commits to a follow-up time and a reason for every lead it rejects. Both review one shared report monthly to adjust and improve the SLA continuously as the pipeline changes.

Why does sales say the leads are rubbish?

The two teams usually define a good lead differently, and neither definition is written down. In Gartner’s survey of 243 chief sales officers (CSOs) and senior sales leaders, run in late 2024, 49% said sales’ definition of a qualified lead differs greatly from marketing’s.

Leadership often can’t see the gap. Forrester’s 2024 surveys found 82% of C-level B2B leaders call their teams aligned, while 65% of sales and marketing professionals (a separate survey) said their own leaders weren’t. Having been on both sides of that equation myself, I agree with both!

Demo requests start out more credible than the complaint suggests. Chili Piper’s 2025 benchmark, a vendor study of ~4 million form submissions across its customers, found 14.1% of demo-form fills were screened out at the form itself (spam, personal emails or failing the customer’s own criteria).

Marketing’s complaint (slow follow-up) is usually true as well, which is the annoying part. I’d fix the definition first, because a rep who doesn’t trust a lead won’t chase it quickly. Last year I worked with a SaaS team in the Netherlands where sales had completely lost trust in marketing-sourced leads, to the point where some sales reps would actively ignore MQLs and prefer to do the SDR work themselves (despite it not being part of their job description). Rebuilding that trust takes time, commitment and a clean slate for objectively ‘better’ shared definitions. A RevOps consultant / leader is typically a good person to mediate that discussion.

What should a sales and marketing SLA include?

Five clauses, each asking something of both teams. Most SLAs I see are one-sided (usually biased towards the team in which the CRO has direct experience, typically sales), so one team commits and the other sits in judgement.

Clause Marketing commits to Sales commits to Measured by
Definition Leads that fit the ideal customer profile (ICP) and show a buying signal, eg. a demo request or form fill Not rejecting a lead that meets it Acceptance rate by source
Volume A monthly number worked back from target, flagging a shortfall by mid-month Working it with appropriate effort, or redistributing it early if already at capacity Actual leads vs commitment
Follow-up A named owner for every lead, plus a fallback A first touch inside the agreed time (how fast to follow up an inbound lead), and minimum attempts % of leads touched in time
Disposition Taking ‘recycled’ leads back into nurture Accept, reject with a set reason, or recycle, within a day Top rejection reasons
Review Producing and reviewing the report summarising all above metrics Producing and reviewing the report summarising all above metrics Monthly; definition changed quarterly at most

How do you set marketing’s lead commitment?

Work back from the revenue target, using your own conversion rates. For an illustrative seed-stage team (round numbers, not client data): £150k of new annual recurring revenue (ARR) this quarter ÷ £15k average deal = 10 wins → ÷ 25% win rate = 40 opportunities → ÷ 50% meeting-to-opportunity = 80 meetings → ÷ 40% lead-to-meeting = 200 leads (ie. ~67 a month). If you don’t know your own rates, finding them stage by stage comes first.

Then check it’s possible. In a 2021 essay for the LinkedIn B2B Institute, John Dawes estimates ~5% of business buyers are in the market in a given quarter, for things bought about once every five years (a heuristic, he says, so adjust it for how often your buyers re-buy). An ICP of 2,000 companies gives ~100 in market, so 200 leads means two from every one. Either the volume comes down or conversion goes up, or ICP needs to be expanded (which then may negatively impact conversion rates, requiring even more volume), which is why the definition and the number get agreed together. Team and campaign budgets will then need to be calculated from this to ensure financial feasibility.

How do you know the SLA is being kept?

Build one report (step 5 in the table above) in/from the CRM that both leaders read:

  • Leads delivered against the commitment, by source
  • Share followed up inside the agreed time
  • Acceptance rate
  • Top rejection reasons, by source
  • Pipeline created from accepted leads

Follow-up is usually the weakest line. InsideSales’ 2021 Lead Response Study, a vendor study of 5.7 million inbound leads at 400+ companies, found 57.1% of first call attempts came more than a week after the lead arrived.

In HubSpot (other CRMs are available!), I’d use lifecycle stage for MQL (marketing qualified lead, ie. meets the agreed definition) and SQL (sales qualified lead, ie. a rep has accepted it), plus a rejection reason dropdown that must be filled in. If you include ‘Other’, review it monthly, or it becomes the top reason, and rejection reasons only help if the field stays clean.

In my experience, the first month or two after this process is implemented is chaos. MQL acceptance drops, lead volumes drop, SQL-Opportunity rates increase (but not by enough to compensate for the lack of MQLs coming through). This adjustment period is a necessary evil as you refine what is acceptable to both sides, and compromise to find a workable middle ground will be inevitable.

Where should a seed-stage team start?

Start small, in this order.

  1. Put both leaders in a room with ten recent ‘rubbish’ leads and ten good ones, and write the definition from the difference (short of recent lead examples? Trace how your last ten wins and losses arrived instead).
  2. Agree the follow-up time and minimum attempts, with a fallback owner.
  3. Make the rejection reason a required CRM field.
  4. Add lead volume requirements once there’s a target to work back from, and reliable conversion rate calculations available.
  5. Review the report monthly, and change the definition quarterly, not weekly (Tip: don’t react too quickly as it takes time to flush leads through the pipeline and understand whether dips are seasonal or temporary).

If you’d like someone neutral in the room for step 1, that’s part of what I do (grab a free consultation/coaching session and we can use it for mediating the meeting).

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an MQL and an SQL?

A marketing qualified lead (MQL) meets the definition both teams agreed: the right fit, plus a buying signal. A sales qualified lead (SQL) is one a rep has spoken to and accepted. The share of MQLs that become SQLs is your acceptance rate.

Does a small team need a formal SLA?

It needs a written one, but it can be short. With one marketer and a founder selling, a definition, a follow-up time, a required rejection reason and a monthly look at the numbers settle most arguments early.

How often should a sales and marketing SLA be reviewed?

Read the shared report monthly. Change the definition quarterly at most, because if it changes every few weeks nobody can tell whether lead quality is improving.

Sources

  1. Gartner Survey Reveals Less Than Half of CSOs Report Their Organization Met Several 2024 Strategic Goals, Gartner (2025)
  2. The Truth About B2B Sales And Marketing Alignment, Forrester (2024)
  3. 2025 Benchmark Report on Demo Form Conversion Rates, Chili Piper (2025)
  4. The 95:5 Rule, John Dawes (Ehrenberg-Bass Institute), for the LinkedIn B2B Institute (2021)
  5. Lead Response Study 2021, InsideSales (2021)

Book a call with Tom

Book a call now!

Calendar not loading? Open it in a new tab